An Open Letter to Christian Parents
By Mary E. Stephens
Nov. 2023
Dear Christian parents,
There is a lot of information being put
out by various groups about how to raise “good, godly” children. There are various
methods promoted, some even will imply or say outright that
their method is the best and will absolutely give the desired
results “if followed correctly.” Some go so far as to
form cult-like groups to keep their children “safe” from not
only the world, but also from the real or imagined problems with other
Christian groups and people - and I do mean real Christians,
just to clarify.
I'm a married Christian woman who has no
children. But, I watched my parents raise two much-younger
siblings, and I have observed a lot of friends and other people
with their children, and I'd like to share some thoughts with you. I
know some people get all uptight about single or childless
people having opinions about raising kids. I understand that because I
know how intrusive some people are with their uninformed
opinions. However, I also know that some of us see real problems
and, because we know our thoughts are not welcome, we are afraid
to say anything. Sometimes they are things that would actually
be helpful to you if you would stop to consider our perspective.
So, I'm writing this with the hope of helping someone who may be feeling overwhelmed with some
aspects of raising children in this day we live in. I doubt
any
honest parent would say they haven't been overwhelmed!
1. There is no foolproof
plan.
The Pearls, Bill Gothard (ATI, IBLP), your pastor, Voddie Baucham,
the Duggars, James Dobson, S.M. Davis, Tedd Tripp, Scott
Brown, and dozens of others, do not have a perfect
plan. They are not experts on your
children. Even you don't know everything about your children. Only your children’s Creator can
claim that role. Only their Creator
should claim that role. In
fact, when parents become obsessed with knowing everything and
controlling everything about their children very bad things can happen. Just sayin'...
There is no perfect formula -
“If we do A and B then C.”
“If we follow this plan perfectly, our
kids will turn out well.”
"If we enforce this set of rules, our
children will be godly."
"If we are 'in church every time the
doors are open' and have family devotions daily, our children
will automatically follow God."
"If we discipline them in just this way,
they will not become terrible sinners."
IMPORTANT -
You cannot protect your children from their own sinfulness - “If we keep them away
from ________ (other kids, bad people, public school, television, the
internet, social media...you fill in the blank) they won’t learn bad things."
Everyone has the same sin nature and no temptation is uncommon.
-
1 Corinthians 10:13 There hath no
temptation taken you but such as is common to man... You
cannot incubate children enough to protect them from their own
sin nature. It’s inside them. It is not your job to fix
that problem. That is what salvation through Christ is all
about. If a human could fix this problem we wouldn't have needed
a Savior.
This is not an excuse to give up, but to
give them the admonition of the Lord and to make sure you follow
and honor His word, not the traditions of man.
Ephesians 6:4 And, ye fathers,
provoke not your children to wrath: but bring them up in the
nurture and admonition of the Lord.
2 Timothy 3:14-15 But continue
thou in the things which thou hast learned and hast been assured
of, knowing of whom thou hast learned them; And that from
a child thou hast known the holy scriptures, which are able to
make thee wise unto salvation through faith which is in Christ
Jesus.
You are not the ones who make your child wise unto
salvation. You give them the word of God and let it do the work
He intends it to through His Spirit.
Hebrews 4:12-13 For the word of God is quick, and
powerful, and sharper than any twoedged sword, piercing even to
the dividing asunder of soul and spirit, and of the joints and
marrow, and is a discerner of the thoughts and intents of
the heart. Neither is there any creature that is not manifest in
his sight: but all things are naked and opened unto the
eyes of him with whom we have to do.
2. You are not responsible to
teach them everything they need to know or to micro-manage
everything that comes into their eyes or ears or minds.
I know this is a hard one for some
parents to accept but, truly, you don’t have to “figure it all
out.” Life is too short and you are too limited to get it right
all the time.
Your job is to try to teach them to
think and to
discern for themselves
before the Lord. It is to
prepare them to see and understand life without you being there,
watching all the time. And, they will need to start doing this at
a much earlier age than many parents imagine. You
should protect them, but you
need to realize that you are not going to do a perfect job. You
need to instruct them so they will be ready and able to
recognize evil when they encounter it - and they will!
Another thing: One of the points of the
body of Christ is that we are to be joined together in a fit way
so that the nourishment of Christ can flow through us.
Ephesians 4:14-16 That we
henceforth be no more children, tossed to and fro, and
carried about with every wind of doctrine, by the sleight of
men, and cunning craftiness, whereby they lie in wait to
deceive; But speaking the truth in love, may grow up into him in
all things, which is the head, even Christ: From whom the
whole body fitly joined together and compacted by that which
every joint supplieth, according to the effectual working in the
measure of every part, maketh increase of the body unto the
edifying of itself in love.
If your
kids are saved, they need to interact with other Christians, not
just your carefully selected “approved” few. The contention
between Paul and Barnabas was so strong (over John Mark) that
they had to part company (Acts 15:36-41). Yet we never read any
warning from Paul about Barnabas, and later he asked for Mark to
be sent to him (2 Tim. 4:11) which admits that Barnabas’ efforts with Mark had
been fruitful. The people we separate from should be only for
really important and biblical reasons. Sadly, there are people who make so many “important” reasons that they cut
themselves off from the body of Christ almost completely. Don’t be those people.
The
"family-inclusive" preoccupation has labeled things like Sunday
School as evil and ungodly. There is nothing wrong with Sunday
School, contrary to what some tell us. There are a lot of things
that are not specifically spelled out in scripture which are useful and/or edifying in some way. Sunday School, as
we know it today, is
not commanded in scripture but it is not forbidden in scripture
either. The same goes for youth groups. (Yes, I know that they
can be a mess in some situations, but they can also be a
blessing in others, so…) Fathers raising their children in the
nurture and admonition of the Lord (Eph. 6:4) does
not mean that
no one else may teach them. Beware of broad brush warnings and
commands appropriated from the Old Testament or interpreted to
suit the teachers’ presuppositions or ideals. God means for the
body of Christ to be an important part of the lives of children as
well as adults.
Note: I do draw the line at so-called
“Jr. church.” There is no reason why the children shouldn’t
worship and learn together with the adults in corporate worship
and teaching. It actually seems unhealthy that they shouldn't.
Learning to sit quietly still for 45 minutes once a week is
actually a useful life skill. However,
Sunday School is not that. It is age appropriate and directed
teaching which certainly can serve a useful purpose and in most
churches is a separate meeting time from the main worship and
preaching
services.
Your kids should also have wholesome
adult friends who are Christians. I had been communicating with the
daughter of a friend of mine at one time. I wasn't sure my
friend knew, so I mentioned it to her when
we were talking on the phone. She told me that she wanted her
children to be friends with older Christians who desired to follow the Lord, even if she didn’t have complete
agreement with them. I was a little surprised, but she went on
to explain that she knew that sometimes kids go to others for advice
or council at some point instead of to their parents, and she
would rather have her children talking to other Christian adults
who had good sense than to people who would lead them away from
the truth. I saw a lot of wisdom in that. I know I did it myself
at times when I was young. Encouraging your children to have good friendships
with other adults in the body of Christ who are walking orderly
before the Lord, even if you don’t agree on everything, is a
safety net you can’t afford to do without, friends. It may mean
the difference between good council and worldly lies at some
point in your kids' lives. If they don't have those kinds of
friendships, who do you think they will go to? Probably not a
good source.
3. Heavy-handed control and
manipulation will give bad results, and may even cause you to lose at least some of
your children.
Heavy control and manipulation may cause your children to rebel and turn away from the
gospel entirely. Or they may become clones of you, your admired
teachers, or your church leaders, following a set path they
think leads to life when they do not even understand true
salvation. Some may be saved and learn to follow the Lord for
themselves, but they may be forced to walk away from you to do
so,
Romans 16:17 Now I beseech you,
brethren, mark them which cause divisions and offences contrary
to the doctrine which ye have learned; and avoid them. I
have known of parents like this, and I’ve known of young people
who followed one of these routes in response to those parents.
A great deal of control and manipulation
happens in the cause of keeping kids "from making the same
mistakes that I/we did." As children grow up, they need to be
allowed to make their own choices in various ways, even when they make mistakes.
If you don’t allow them to ever make choices or mistakes (by your
interpretation), they won’t know how to deal with real life. We
all make mistakes. We all get into situations we wish we hadn’t.
No, you don't need to let them run feral and be little monsters,
but kids who don't learn how to recognize hazards,
avoid mistakes, and take responsibility for their
actions are headed for serious problems. Yes, there will be
situations where you need to step in because you
are the parents and that's
your job. However, there are parents who are so preoccupied with
protecting their kids from running amok and making mistakes that
the children grow up with almost no skills for dealing with
their mistakes and sinful nature. This is dangerous.
It sets them up for failure and even destruction.
Proverbs 4:1-2
Hear, ye children, the instruction of a father, and attend to
know understanding. For I give you good doctrine, forsake ye not
my law.
Romans 14:12 So then every one of us
shall give account of himself to God.
They also need to learn to think for
themselves before God without feeling obligated to seek your
approval. Why? Because you are
not God. You do not know God’s plan for their lives. You are not
the final authority and you don’t have all the answers. Only God
does. They need to learn to communicate with Him directly without reference to your preferences or ideas. Yeah,
that’s hard. But, you can’t imagine what a
difference it will make in their lives. I hate to think
where I would be if my parents hadn't granted me this freedom.
Certainly they corrected and instructed me, but they desired for my
siblings and me to have a good relationship with the Lord on our own. They wanted us to walk worthy of what God wanted for us without
someone constantly looking over our shoulders to make sure we
were doing it "the right way."
Ephesians 4:1 I therefore, the prisoner of the Lord, beseech you
that ye walk worthy of the vocation wherewith ye are called,
Romans 12:9 Let love be without dissimulation.
Abhor that which is evil; cleave to that which is good.
DISSIMULATION, n. L., to make like; like. The act
of dissembling; a hiding under a false appearance; a
feigning; false pretension; hypocrisy. Dissimulation may
be simply concealment of the opinions, sentiments or
purpose; but it includes also the assuming of a false or
counterfeit appearance which conceals the real opinions
or purpose... (Webster, 1828) |
Don’t put on airs of false humility
pretending that raising children is a huge responsibility so
that you can lord it over your children and demand absolute,
unthinking obedience. Kids are not stupid. Soon or later, they
will see through this ruse. I understand why some parents
tell their kids, "Spanking you hurts me more than it does you."
But, truthfully, folks, there are people who say that more to
manipulate their children's minds and increase their guilt than
out of any kind of sincerity. Don't be those parents.
Acknowledge your sins to your children
and even apologize to them when you have sinned against them.
This is one of the things that made a huge impression on me at
an early age with my own dad. I remember him apologizing to me
once when he spanked me for something my brother had done. I was
impressed in my teens by my Gramma apologizing to me when we had
had a misunderstanding and both had sinned against the other.
And, another time I was impressed with an older friend who
apologized to her children when she had been very grumpy with
them all day and she even stopped and asked them to pray for
her, which they did. To see your parent or grandparent humble
themselves before you and admit they are not just a sinner, but
that they have sinned against you, is worth more than many, many
sermons on humility and repentance. It can’t be faked, though,
or it will have the exact opposite effect, so do it in sincerity
and truth.
James 5:16 Confess
your faults one to another, and pray one for another...
4. You are not ultimately responsible for
your children’s salvation.
You can't get saved for you kids, nor
can you make them get saved. You are responsible to give them
the gospel of Jesus Christ so that they will hopefully understand it.
You are
responsible to live out the gospel before them. But, you cannot
make sure they are saved.
I have heard of some parents
who actually believed that their children would automatically be
Christians because they are or because they have a “covenant
home.” This is in essence, a form of believing that your
children inherit eternal life from you. Since eternal life can
only come from God, this is a false gospel, even heresy. Sadly, some people with this
ideology actually fail to give their children the gospel of
Jesus Christ, thus leading to people who grow up thinking they
are saved when, in fact, they are not. If they continue
this path, in just a few generations there
can be whole large groups of people who think they are saved
because they were born and raised in a “Christian” home but
none, or few, of them are truly born again. I’ve seen this among the
various Reformed people of Western Michigan, and others.
Some parents may become so distraught
over the fact that their children are not saved that they will
become overbearing in giving the gospel or trying to “help”
their children get “under conviction.” This can be a serious
problem. Kids may actually get to the point where they are afraid
to get saved because of what they perceive as the high demands
for holiness, or they may reject the gospel because they become
hardened to their parents’ constant pushing. Don’t let this
happen in your home. Try to be consistent in your own
testimony - to both talk and live out the way of life - but let the Holy
Spirit do His job of reproving their conscience. He knows
exactly what each child needs to show them their
need of salvation. You
don’t. No actually, you don't.
Also, you cannot spank your children into becoming Christians.
Sadly, some people appear to think this way based on some
twistings of scripture.
John 16:13-14
Howbeit when he, the Spirit of truth,
is come, he will guide you into all truth: for he shall not
speak of himself; but whatsoever he shall hear, that
shall he speak: and he will shew you things to come. He shall
glorify me: for he shall receive of mine, and shall shew it
unto you.
And
by the way, just because your child takes longer to get saved
than you expected or than someone else's kids did, that doesn't
mean you failed. One sad case I heard of was a father whose
son realized when he was a young adult that he was not truly
born again and he got saved. Reportedly, the father, instead of
rejoicing with the angels in heaven because one sinner had
repented, was sad because he said he failed as a father since it
had taken his son so long to get saved. You know what's really
sad? That that man's opinion of himself drowned his Christian
joy at seeing his son come to Christ. He was so focused on
himself and his duties as a father that he lost sight of what
really mattered. That is a tragedy.
5. Seek out godly
accountability and wisdom. Don’t think that you can figure it
all out alone, but also don’t go seeking out teachers to follow
who don’t even know you or your family.
Often times, parents seek teachers based
on the fact that they are saying what they want to hear or what
they think they need to hear. This may have nothing to do with
the truth of God’s word or His will.
If you younger mothers don’t seek
council from the godly older women in your lives, you are in the wrong. How
can they teach you the Titus 2 things if you won’t ask or listen? Even
some women who made mistakes may have useful things to impart.
If they acknowledge their mistakes, as one elderly lady whom I
looked up to did, they can impart wisdom based on what not to
do. And just to be clear, if don't include older, godly women in
your circle of friends, you need to examine your choices,
because that
isn't even biblical.
People who are closer to you and your
family will likely observe things that need to be brought to
your attention. This is the very reason that some people want to
seek advice and teaching from someone over the horizon who will
never likely see their family, or only in a controlled
environment if they do. Some parents don’t want to know the
truth about their methods or to deal with
their own faults. They
want to follow a “perfect plan” that someone assures them “will
work” and not be accountable to anyone who might point out their
own sin or flawed thinking. Is that you? Please consider carefully. The
consequences of making this mistake are too horrible to
disregard.
It is really sad to see parents who are
so set on their "perfect plan" that no one can talk to them
about the obvious mistakes they are making with their children.
When parents are so self-assured and superior in their own ideas
that they cannot be approached by the people nearest to them who
love them and their kids, something is terribly amiss, and the
results won't be good.
1
Thessalonians 5:11-15 Wherefore comfort yourselves together,
and edify one another, even as also ye do. And we beseech you,
brethren, to know them which labour among you, and are over you
in the Lord, and admonish you; And to esteem them very highly in
love for their work's sake. And be at peace among
yourselves. Now we exhort you, brethren, warn them that are
unruly, comfort the feebleminded, support the weak, be patient
toward all men. See that none render evil for evil unto
any man; but ever follow that which is good, both among
yourselves, and to all men.
The body of Christ is meant to edify, admonish, warn, comfort,
and support one another. You have to be part of the local group
of believers in order to obey these things. You also have to
listen when
someone approaches you with a problem they have observed.
6. Take responsibility where it
is rightfully yours.
Some parents seem to think that because
they are part of a church, this will ensure their children are
taught and instructed “properly.” There seems to be some
entitlement thinking coming to some Christians where they
believe that certain aspects of training and instruction should
be done for them by the church.
It is not the responsibility of the
church to give your kids their basic education. A church school
might be a nice thing to have, but it is not an entitlement or
expectation. It is also not the responsibility of any school -
public, charter, private, or Christian. You are responsible to
make sure your children are educated properly. My parents
discovered that my brother was not being taught properly by his
1st grade teacher because she was ignoring him. He was one of the few quiet boys in her large class
of mostly rowdy boys. They
had to make a decision to make sure that he got the education he
needed. They chose to put him in a Christian school and they
followed up and made sure he was learning more there – which he
did. (That amazing Christian school teacher taught him all of 1st grade
in half the school year!)
It is your responsibility to teach your
kids basic manners among other people.
You teach them to sit
quietly in church meetings. The church is not obligated to
provide you with free daycare so that you can "have a break
during church." Sure, that might be nice if it’s there, but it is
not your entitlement. I'm pretty sure that the nursery and "Jr.
church" are fairly new innovations in church life when you
consider that we're 2000 years into it now. Many Christian
parents have done without and never considered that they were
being "cheated."
You also are the ones who should teach
your children to behave respectfully toward other people in the
congregation – not running around elderly people, speaking
politely to their elders, not being mean to other kids, not
making pests of themselves with people who are trying to have a
conversation, not screaming inside at the top of their lungs just for
fun, etc. No, children aren’t going to behave perfectly and no
sensible person would expect them to, although some non-sensible
people might. But, it’s bothersome to hear parents complain
about having to take care of the children they chose to bring
into the world. It’s also frustrating to see parents ignore or
even excuse their children’s bad behavior as if they weren't
responsible or it didn’t matter.
Ephesians 6:4
And, ye fathers, provoke not your children to wrath: but bring
them up in the nurture and admonition of the Lord.
Fathers are commanded to bring their
children up in the nurture and admonition of the Lord – not the
pastor, not the church, not the Sunday School teachers, not the
Christian school teachers. All of those may add useful things in
a child’s growing up years, but it is the father’s
responsibility to do the main up bringing in these areas.
Mothers and grandparents also are responsible to teach the
scriptures as we know from the fact that Lois and Eunice taught
Timothy to know the scriptures “from a child,” and they
were commended by the Holy Ghost through Paul. (1
Tim. 1:3-5)
Ask for advice or help if you need it. But, don’t expect others to do what you are
commanded to do in scripture.
Due
to worldly wisdom and ideas that are spreading in the church, I
feel like I need to say this too: It's part of your job to spank
your kids when they need it. If you live in a country where that
is not allowed, then you need to come up with other means of
disciplining your children. The biblical principle is to chasten
and spank with reproof, but spanking isn't an absolute command
in the teachings to the New Testament church. Just sayin'...
(Neither side of the "absoluters" will like this. Parents these
days either absolutely don't want to spank at all, or they think
it's an absolutely nonnegotiable command. Based on what the
Bible actually says, I believe the truth lies somewhere in
between.)
And for those nay-sayers that want to
say that the rod of the Old Testament isn't speaking of the rod
of discipline:
Proverbs 23:13
Withhold not correction from the child: for if thou
beatest him with the rod, he shall not die. Just to
be clear, that isn't the "comforting rod." It's the rod that is
used to underscore reproof.
Proverbs 29:15
The rod and reproof give wisdom: but a child left to himself
bringeth his mother to shame.
Don't get
yourself all tied in knots over that. Take it in context of what
Jesus said about offending little ones and don't assume God
means that children should be abused. Let's honor the God who
is
love with the respect and trust to believe that He wouldn't
recommend child beating as some people teach it today.
Proverbs 22:15
Foolishness is bound in the heart of a child; but
the rod of correction shall drive it far from him.
Hebrews 12:5-6
And ye have forgotten the exhortation which speaketh unto you as
unto children, My son, despise not thou the chastening of the
Lord, nor faint when thou art rebuked of him: For whom the Lord
loveth he chasteneth, and scourgeth every son whom he receiveth.
While we're mentioning this verse, it
should probably be pointed out that not every Christian gets the
same kind of chastening or scourging. We get corrected by God in
ways that are suitable to our listening and learning skills. Let
that guide your manner of correcting your own children. Make it
age and mentality appropriate. My family has cringed over
parents who spanked their kids for every tiny infringement of
their wishes and commands. We've also been shocked at those who
encourage spanking small babies - those too young to receive
reproof and understand what it means. When the discipline is without
reproof (explanation) or is a constant flow of punishment, don't be
surprised if the kids eventually rebel and turn on you and your
God with anger.
In conclusion:
I hope you realize that I did not give
much specific child rearing advice here. I didn’t offer any
rules about bed times or sleep overs or diet requirements or
exactly how to discipline or any
of the thousands of subjects that various experts like to
pontificate upon. Hopefully you also realize the reason is that
I’m trying to point you back to the Lord and His word and your
local fellowship of believers - the accountability and sources of help that
you should be looking to in the first place.
I probably sound like
a broken record, but I see so much failure in this area that I
find it hard to believe I can mention it too much:
examine everything by the word of God. Stop following
men and their traditions (old or new), and their allegedly
“perfect plans.” Stop accepting human interpretation of
scripture without considering it and examining it for yourself.
Just because someone says "The Bible says..." doesn't mean they
are telling the truth or in context! Check up on them!
Follow Jesus. Get to know Him and His word, so
that when your kids are grown - whether they are saved or not -
they will be able to say “I saw Jesus in my
parents.” Some parents are so busy making sure they raise their
kids just right to get the exact outcome they want, they forget
that they themselves should be growing
"in grace and in the
knowledge of our Lord and Saviour, Jesus Christ." (2
Peter 3:18) They miss the point that if they don’t do that,
they will not be able to
live a “Christ-life outpoured” before their children.
Life is short. The time your children
are in your home is generally much shorter. The greatest thing
you will ever give them is an example of
following Christ
with others who call on God out of pure a heart. Make the most
of it.
2 Timothy 2:22
Flee also youthful lusts: but follow righteousness, faith,
charity, peace, with them that call on the Lord out of a pure
heart.
|